LISTS OF THE PIONEERS

"In solving the question as to who were the real pioneers of Simcoe County, one important event readily furnishes us with a key. The Rebellion of 1837 is a distinct dividing line, in relation to which those who settled before it were the real pioneers of the county, the period to which they belonged standing out by itself, sharp and clear. It is with this period that the contents of this second volume mainly deal, except where it became necessary to comlete the History by introducing such persons and events of the subsequent years as seemed requisite, especially the more prominent of those who took part in the public affairs of the county.
Two or three years after the troubles of the Rebellion were at an end, other settlers began to flock in once more, and the stream of immigration and settlement was kept up to present times. But the hardships of those who settled after the Rebellion do not compare in severity with those of the people who came before it. In so far, then, as this volume is a monument to the memory of the early settlers and pioneers of the county, however imperfect it maybe, its scope is clearly defined as to time by the Rebellion, and by the cessation of the flow of settlement to the district for a few years thereafter, which marks off the preceding time into a distinct period by itself---the period of the true pioneers.
To build a monument to any group of persons, and complete it, there is at least one thing necessary, viz., to give their names. This is not so easy in the present case as it may appear to be, but the following collection of about 1800 names makes some approach to completeness, and at all event will be a useful working list for the benefit of other workers in this line of research.
In seeking for a basis of the pioneer lists, the writer found that George Walton's Home District Directory for 1837 contained somes lists of those who were believed to be actual setlers at the date of its publication. The lists in this directory, however, had many mistakes and needed much editing, which was not an easy task after the lapse of more than seventy years. They were full of misprints, misspelled names and other errors, and did not contain full lists. Besides, no lists appeared for two townships, which at the time the Directory was prepared, had been outlying areas with only a few settlers, viz., Nottawasaga and Tosorontio, so it became necessary to construct entirely new lists for these two townships.
Amongst the various sources of information that the present writer had to use for the further improvement of Walton's lists, which were adopted as the basis, the Patent lists for the various townships proved to be helpful, and were used to supply fuller particulars as well as a number of corrections. But the Patent lists contain the names of many who were not actual settlers, being merely the owners of the land in its wild condition, and accordingly this source of information was of limited value for making the lists complete. In most cases also, the actual settler received his patent long after settlement, so the lists were not serviceable as to date of settlement, although they showed frequently who the original settler was.
It is to be feared, therefore, that these lists as they here stand have still a few errors, but they are an approach to the truth. Doubtless, they still contain a few names of U. E. Loyalists, who received lands but did not become actual settlers. As it was not easy to distinguish these in the lists in every case, from actual settlers, it was deemed advisable not to elide any name but such as was actually known to be not an original settler at any tme."

Andrew Frederick Hunter 1863 - 1940

SETTLERS BEFORE 1837

The Villages

WEST GWILLIMBURY

SETTLER
ALGEO, Lewis
ARMSON, William
ARMSTRONG, Christopher
ARMSTRONG, John
ARMSTRONG, Robert
ARMSTRONG, Thomas
ARMSTRONG, William
ARMSTRONG, Thomas
ATKINS, Robert
ATKINS, Robert
BANKS, E. (Negro)
BANNERMAN, George
BANNERMAN, Donald
BANNERMAN, Alex,
BANNERMAN, Hugh
BARRETT, William
BAWDY, John (Boddy)
BELFRY, Iro
BELFRY, JAMES,
BELFRY, Philo
BELFRY, Prince
BELL, James
BLAIR, Wm.
BOWLES, George
BOSTWICK, John
BOSTWICK, Edward
BRANDON, John
BRANDON, Thomas
BRANDON, Matthew
BRANDON, John
BRANDON, Robert
BRAZIER, John
BRAZIL, Michael
BRADY, Robert
BROWN, Philip
BROWN, James
BURNS, Christopher
CAFFREY, William
CAMPBELL, Arthur
CAMPBELL, Robert
CARRUTHERS, Wm.
CARNEY, Patrick (Kearney)
CASTRO, Henry
CASTOR, William
CAYTON, John
CHRISTY, John
CLARK, Ira
CLEMENT, George
COBURN, John, Sr.
COBURN, John, Jr.
COLEY, George
COLLINS, William
COLLINS, Richard
CONDELL, John (Cundel)
CONWAY, James
CORBETT, Christopher
CORBETT, Joseph
COSGRAVE, William
COSGRAVE, Archibald
COULSON, Robert,
COULSON, John
CREIGHTON, Samuel
CRONAN, John
CRONAN, James
CRONAN, Thomas
CRONAN, Edward
CUNNINGHAM, Wm.
CUNNINGHAM, ANDREW
CURRY, John
DALEY, John
DAVIS, John
DAVIS, James
DERRY, Alexander
DEVIT, John, Sr.
DEVIT, John, Jr.
DIMOND, James
DISSETT, John
DISSETT, Philip
DOAN, Jonathan
DOAN, James
DOAN, John
DOAN, Ebenezer
DODDS, James
DOWNEY, Robert
ELLIOTT, Francis
ENGLISH, Gilbert
EVANS, James
EVANS, George
EVANS, John
FEAGAN, Wm. (Fiegehen)
FENNELL, Joseph
FENNELL, John
FERGUSON, James
FERRIS, John
FERRIS, John
FISHER, John
FLANAGAN, Patrick
FOSTER, John
FOWLER, William
FOWLIS, Charles
FRASER, John
FRASER, William
FRASER, William, Rev.
FRYE, Henry
GARBUTT, John
GARBUTT, William
GALLOWAY, James
GIBBONS, Patrick
GOODFELLOW, John
GOODFELLOW, Adam
GOULD, John
GRANT, Hector
GREER, Matthew
GREER, William
GREER, Patrick
GREENFIELD, James
GUNN, Alex
GUNN, Alex
HARDGRAVE, William
HAIL, Lowell
HERRICAN, Andrew
HENDERSON, Thomas
HILL, James
HODGSON, Joseph
HUFF, John
HUGHES, Samuel
HUNTER, James
HUTCHINSON, James
JACKSON, Nathan
JEBB, Thomas
JEFFS, Edward
JOHNSON, Joseph
JOHNSTON, Isaac
JOHNSTON, Robert
JONES, Humphrey
KERR, Alexander
KERR, John
KEENAN, Dominick
KELLY, John
KIDD, James
KITLEY, Joseph
KITLEY, John
KNEESHAW, William
LANDERKIN, James
LATIMORE, John
LAWRENCE, Alex
LAWRENCE, James
LEE, Patrick
LEE, Henry
LEE, John
LEE, Thomas
LEWIS, John
LEWIS, George
LLOYD, Charles
LLOYD, Charles
LONG, James
LONG, John
Long, Richard
LONG, Samuel
MACAULEY, John
McDOWELL, Wildredge
MACKEE, William (McKee)
MAGEE, John
McGEE, Richard
McGEE, James
McGEE, Edward
MATCHETT, Thomas
MATCHETT, Edward
MATTHEWS, Wm.
MATTICE, Thomas
MATHESON, John
MATHESON, John
MEGAN, Lawrence
MEGAN, John
MEGAN, James
MERRICK, Mary
MILLS, James
MILLS, James
MILLER, Thomas
MOLLOY, Charles
MOLLOY, Garrett
MOLLOY, William
MOLLOY, Timothy
MOLLOY, John
MOORE, Joseph
MORARITY, Owen
MORARITY, Michael
McARTHUR, Angus
McBETH, Charles
McBETH, Andrew
McAFEE, John
McCARROLL, Hugh
McARTHUR, William
McARTHUR, Oliver
McARTHUR, Robert
McCAUSLAND, Alex
McCLENNON, John
McDONALD, Donald
McKAY, William
McKAY, Alex
McKAY, Donald
McKAY, Roderick
McKAY, Alex
McKAY, George
McKAY, James
McKENNEY, Neil
McKILLICAN, Wm.
McLean, Widow
McLELLAN, William
McLELLAN, Alex
McLEOD, Hector
McMAHON, Thomas
NAY, Matthew
NAY, Robert
NEILLY, Wm.
NEILLY, Samuel
NELSON, John
NESBITT, John
NEWRY, Wm. (Nowrey)
O'CONNELL, Darby
O'DONNELL, John
O'DONNELL, Richard
PARKER, Thomas
PARKER, Robert
PATFIELD, James (Padfield)
PENROSE, Yarnel
PHILLIPS, Wm.
PILKINGTON, James
PORTER, Oliver
Procter, Samuel
Proctor, Thomas
QUAY, John
QUIGLEY, Charles
QUIGLEY, Wm.
RAINEY, Wm.
RAMSAY, Wm.
READ, John
ROBINS, Henry
ROBINSON, Gilbert
ROBINSON, Peter
ROBINSON, Joel, F.
ROBINSON, Wm.
ROBINSON, John
ROBERTS, Wm.
ROBERTS, John
ROE, William
ROGERS, Elias
ROGERS, Dennis
ROGERS, Levi
ROGERS, James
Rogers, Isaac
ROGERS, Isaiah
ROGERS, E.
ROONY, Thomas
ROSE, John
ROSS, George
ROSS, Sandy
RUTLEDGE, John
SAWYER, Robert
SCANLAN, Patrick
SCANLAN, Mark
SCANLAN, Cornelius
SCOBIE, Hugh
SLOAN, John
SLOAN, William
SMITH, Phelps
SMITH, Ralph
SPARLING, George
STEELE, James
STEELE, Hugh
STEELE, Thomas
STEVENS, Wm.
STIGMEY, Levi
STINSON, Wm.
STINSON, George
STINSON, George
STONE, Solomon
STODDART, Wm.
STODDART, Wm.
STODDART, John
STODDART, James
STODDART, Hugh
SUTHERLAND, Robert
SUTHERLAND, William
SUTHERLAND, Donald
SUTHERLAND, Angus
SUTHERLAND, Haman
SUTHERLAND, John
SUTHERLAND, John
SUTHERLAND, Thomas
SUTHERLAND, Wm.
TASKER, Mark
THORNBURY, Wm.
THORPE, George
THORPE, William
THORPE, John
TINDALL, James
TOWSE, Richard
TROTTER, James
VANSTOCK, Garrett
VARNAM, James
WALKER, Wm.
WALLACE, John
WALLACE, James
WARDMAN, Wm.
WARDMAN, John
WATERS, James
WELLS, James
WEST, Thomas
WEST, George
WEST, Benjamin
WHITE, William
WHITESIDE, William
WILLARD, Asa
WILLIAMS, Moses
WILLOUGHBY, Ralph
WILLOUGHBY, John
WILSON, Benjamin
WILSON, Hugh
WILSON, John
WOOD, James
WOOD, William

Con.
7
7
6
6
6
6
5
7
8
9
9
4
3
5
6
9
10
8
8
8
8
13
13
9
3
4
1
2
2
2
2
5
7
10
7
11
9
9
6
7
7
7
6
6
13
6
8
14
10
9
4
5
7
13
10
3
3
14
14
10
11
2
12
12
12
12
6
5
9
8
3
11
9
1
1
9
7
12
7
7
10
3
4
9
12
12
10
10

9
13
10
10
6
6
7
8
3
12
3
9
3
5
6
2
13
12
11
9
7
6
10
3
8
11
9
10
5
4
7
7
9
11
11
6
7
2
11
9
13
11
6
10
3
13
6
10
10
9
9
14
3
4
14
6
9
10
10
11
11
11
11
7
7
3
2
8
8
9
9
7
11
2
8
8
8
9
10
10
12
12
6
5
8
9
8
2
3
6
9
7
9
13
10
12
4
7
10
2
4
5
12
13
11
11
12
9
5
5
4
4
4
4
4
4
6
11
6
11
11
4
6
5
7
8
12
13
6
14
9
13
13
14
8
8
14
2
6
10
6
8
8
11
11
11
6
1
2
6
8
5
7
8
9
11
11
2
2
3
3
7
8
10
10
7
4
4
7
9
14
9
9
9
7
8
9
6
9
7
11
11
12
7
4
3
3
10
5
7
8
8
7
8
5
5
5
5
5
6
8
8
4
10
5
10
10
12
12
13
10
6
9
11
2
6
7
9
10
7
5
6
6
9
9
10
2
7
9
5
6
13
11
13

Lot
13
5
9
12
13
11
12
8
5
1
9
6
7
9
10
10
12
14
16
14
16
17
13
11
3
4
2
3 (W1/2)
5 (S pt.)
2
4
3
1 (S1/2)
18 (N1/2)
6
15
15 (S1/2)
17
10
4 (N1/2)
4 (S1/2)
6 (N1/2)
1
1
15 (N1/2)
4
3 (E 1/2)
15
1 (N1/2)
2 (S1/2)
1
4
8
10
6 (S1/2)
1
4
13
16
13 (NW1/4)
15 (S1/2)
4
20
15
19
15
2 (N1/2)
1 (N1/2)
14
7
1
8 (N1/2)
4
1
1
5
16
9
3
1
12
2
3
4
9
12 (S1/2)
14
14
13
16
17
1
6
8 (S1/2)
7
6 (N1/2)
10
17
3
4
8
9
1
5
13 (S1/2)
13 (N1/2)
6
1
14 (S1/2)
8
12
7
13 (N1/2)
16
13 (S1/2)
19
9 (S1/2)
3 (N1/2)
16
12 (N1/2)
6
15
1 (S1/2)
9 (N1/2)
12
1
8
9
11
10
3
4
4
7 (S1/2)
1
7 (S1/2)
9 (S1/2
8
5
1
2
3
14
2
1
5
5
15
2 (S1/2)
3 (S1/2)
4
2
2
5
2
1
4
5
2
8
13 (S1/2)
15
4
8 (S1/2)
8 (N1/2)
8
4 (N1/2)
2 (N1/2)
11 (N1/2)
10
7
10 (N1/2)
12
12
11
2
4
3
14
6
13
13 (N1/2)
13
19
2
16
13 (S1/2)
4
9 (N1/2)
7
8
10
7
8
6
13 (E1/2)
11
11
5
11 (N1/2)
10 (E1/2)
10 (W1/2)
1
5
7
10
5
16 (S1/2)
19 (N1/2)
7 (S1/2)
6
7
7 (N1/2)
11
17
8
1
17
5
9 (N1/2)
18 (S1/2
19 (N1/2
10 (S1/2)
10 (N1/2)
16
2
1
6 (N1/2)
10 (N1/2)
2
3 (W1/2)
19 (E1/2)
13
13 (N1/2)
14 (N1/2)
10
2
6 (S1/2)
15
13
1
15
16
17 (N1/2)
18 (N1/2)
3
1
3
3
8
12
3 (S1/2)
15
17
4
7 (N1/2)
7
10 (S1/2)
17
6 (N1/2)
16
7 (S1/2)
13
17
18 (S1/2)
5
3
5
11
11
7
11
6
5
5
9
4
10 (S1/2)
7
9
10 (N1/2)
9 (N1/2)
8 (S1/2)
5 (S1/2)
5 (N1/2)
10 (S1/2)
12 (S1/2)
1
1
6 (S1/2)
8
16
10
16
17
14
16 (N1/2)
15
3
11
7
2
1
14
14
3
4
14 (N1/2)
2
6
4
10
4
11
4
4
1
1
4
11
16 (N1/2)
15


Back to Simcoe